Can you imagine the justice / fascistic law enforcement a giant-sized Judge Dredd would rain down?
Costumed heroes have never fared well in the eyes of Judge Dredd, and Superman isn’t going to be an exception.
Dredd’s had plenty of experience with surfers so one more isn’t going to worry him too much.
In terms of sheer strength, sure, the Hulk’s got this.
For will and determination, though, you can’t discount Dredd.